LANGUAGE AND NATIONALISM. BULGARIAN-MACEDONIAN LANGUAGE DISPUTE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE SIGNED TREATY OF GOOD NEIGHBOURSHIP BETWEEN TWO COUNTRIES
Abstract
Theories of nations and nationalism consider language as one of
the important factors that define the basis of a nation. The language
dispute between Bulgaria and Macedonia is not a recent issue. In its very
sharp form it exists since the second half of 19th century when the two
views were determined: one which embraced a common linguistic
standard for Macedonians and Bulgarians; and the position of the so
called makedonisti, who insisted that a separate linguistic development
for Macedonian nation must be introduced. With the codification of the
Macedonian linguistic standard in 1944, the language dispute with
Bulgaria reached another dimension. Following the proclamation of the
Macedonian Independence and their recognition by Bulgaria in 1992, a
number of contracts of mutual cooperation remained unsigned due to the
linguistic dispute. A breakthrough was made in 1999 when the
Declaration for Good Neighbourship was signed in Macedonian language
in accordance with the Constitution, and Bulgarian language in
accordance with the Bulgarian Constitution, and a formulation which was
also accepted when the Treaty of Good Neighbourship was signed in
- The purpose of this paper is to use the historical and explicative
approach to explain the genesis of Bulgarian - Macedonian language
dispute, especially its escalation following the codification of the
Macedonian standard language in 1944/1945. Analysis was performed
with the comparative approach, which included analogies with other
national linguistic contexts for the unsustainability of the Bulgarian thesis
for non-existence of an independent Macedonian language. A special
review was carried out due to the dilemma on whether the formulation
from the Treaty “Language in accordance to the Constitution” was
Bulgaria’s attempt to devalue and deny the autochthony of the
Macedonian language as an important marker of the Macedonian nation.