Ignorance and Yugoslavia: A Causal Explanation of Yugoslavia’s Disintegration?
Abstract
Keutner (2004), in investigating the scientific methods in history, formulates the Principle of Ignorance as key for any causal explanation: The causal agent is not aware of the causal force until it impacts, causing the effect. On the other hand, historical explanations often involve narratives of action, intention, desires and beliefs. The culminating question of Keutner’s research is whether there is room for causal explanations by using the Principle of Ignorance in history. This paper will show that causality fails to deliver a sufficient explanation for the disintegration of Yugoslavia. This failure itself, however, can be informative allowing the reshaping of the discussion away from normativity toward a more fine-grained approach.
Key words: Yugoslavia, philosophy of history, causality, ethnicity, Milosevic
Downloads
References
Anderson, David (1995):The Collapse of Yugoslavia, Background and Summary. Canberra (Research paper 14: Australian Parliamentary Research Service).
Bratman, Michael (2010): “Agency, Time, and Sociality”.Proceedings of the American Philosophical Association 84, H. 2: 7-26.
Calic, Marie-Janine (2010):Geschichte Jugoslawiens im 20. Jahrhundert.München.
Churchland, Paul M. (1981): "Eliminative materialism and the propositional attitudes".The Journal of Philosophy 78, H. 2. 67-90.
Danto, Arthur C. (1973):Analytical philosophy of action. Cambridge.
Davidson, Donald (1970).:"Mental Events".Actions and Events.Oxford.
DragovicSoso,Jasna (2007): “Why Did Yugoslavia Disintegrate?”.in: Cohen, Lenard J. andDragovic-Soso,Jasna (eds.):State collapse in South-Eastern Europe: new perspectives on Yugoslavia's disintegration. West Lafayette. 1-39.
Dray, William H. (1964):Philosophy of History. London.
Ingrao, Charles and ThomasA. Emmert (eds.) (2009):Confronting the Yugoslav Controversies. A Scholars’ Initiative. West Lafayette.
Keutner Thomas (2004): Ignoranz, Täuschung, Selbsttäuschung: Kausalität in den Handlungswissenschaften. München.
Stout, Robert (2005). Action. Durham.
Sundhausen, Holm (1994): „Ethnonationalismus in Aktion: Bemerkungen zum Ende Jugoslawiens“. Geschichte und Gesellschaft 20. 402-423.
Permissions
Authors are expected to obtain permission from copyright holders for reproducing any illustrations, tables, figures or lengthy quotations previously published elsewhere. BSSR will not be held accountable for any copyright infringement caused by the authors.
Copyright
The content offered in the BSSR remains the intellectual property of the authors and their publishers respectively. University “Goce Delcev”- Shtip, R. Macedonia and BSSR keap the right to promote and re-publish the texts.
